Jimmy was a close business friend of Jackie Estacado. He and Frankie were attacked by Barzini's Vampires, Frankie was killed while Jimmy was taken to be fed on and turned by Vampires. He was taken to a bar full of Vampires and Werewolves were Jackie found him. He told Jackie as much as he could before asking him to kill him, to which Jackie agreed. After Eva killed all the monsters in the bar, she noticed Jimmy still alive. He asked about Jackie and she told him he was safe, which relieved Jimmy and uncovered the identity of The Darkness to Eva. Eve then staked and killed him.